Scientia Potentia Est: Amity & Sorrow by Peggy Riley

With a name like O’Connor, you have to be Catholic®.

True statement and meant to be said like the silly jam commercial, though it’s certainly not a registered trademark. However is there any O’Connor out there willing to admit they were not raised at least nominally Catholic?

Growing up Catholic taught me quite a bit – lest you think Catholicism is all peace and prayer, you can actually ‘out Catholic’ others (see Stephen Colbert and Jack White), Ash Wednesday is the longest day of the year (only non-Catholics think it’s in June), the only day you ever crave meat is Friday (to torture yourself?), and celibacy is the only real perversion (Oscar Wilde, wise man).

I shouldn’t poke fun, but as you might imagine, I do, in fact, come from a staunchly Irish Catholic family. Being a member of such a family, I received my own personal portions of guilt, fish, mass, and Latin. I have since left the church, though my grandmother insists on calling it a lapse (and don’t you dare say the a-word in front of her). So it was with mild trepidation that I approached Peggy Riley’s religion-laced Amity & Sorrow, which I picked up initially because I found the title to both simple and compelling.

Amity Sorrow

Amity and Sorrow are two sisters that lead a seemingly idyllic life. They live on an isolated farm with their large family, homegrown food, and a community of love. The idyll loses a little bit of the appeal when you realize the children have one father and 50 mothers. The image is further damaged when you realize the adults require and encourage absolute ignorance in the children.

Suddenly and without warning, Amaranth drags her two daughters away from their home, driving for four days straight. She crashes their car in Oklahoma, stranding herself and her daughters – leaving their fate to beleaguered farmer Bradley. Teenage Sorrow, suffering a much needed miscarriage, longs to return to the compound and her father to await the end of the world. Younger sister Amity is confused about what it happening, and furthermore, about what is good and right. Amaranth is the only one with any real world experience, having lived in California prior to marrying the future polygamist Zachariah. Their small family must adapt to the modern world, despite Sorrow’s unwillingness to do so.

Amity & Sorrow is an interesting novel. It’s very much a meditation on the meaning of love and family. What we’re willing to do for it, the way we use it for justification, and how we hide behind it. It’s also about knowledge (and lack thereof) and the power it can wield. It’s only mildly about God, despite a religious cult being at the forefront of the plot.

Neither Sorrow nor Amity has any experience in modern society. Through Amity you get to experience the joy of books, television, computers, and junk food (yes, junk food is a joy, albeit a perverse one). In Sorrow you see the devastating consequences of a life of indulgence and indoctrination. Sorrow believes she is the oracle sent to speak God’s word and that she will birth baby Jesus – she is violent in her effort to achieve her goals and unwilling (and unable) to acknowledge the abuse she’s endured. Both girls have been denied any type of education, instead living by ‘rules’ that govern life – no going in fields, no entering a man’s house, women must bind their body and cover their hair, etc.

Knowledge was power, but ignorance was holy. It kept them humble and pliable, docile and safe as milk cows.

Zachariah abuses their ignorance, denying them the ability to function in society, yet preventing them from living a real life in their isolation. If that’s not disturbing enough, consider who the father of Sorrow’s baby might be, their communal wedding nights, or Zachariah’s meth lab (the inspiration behind the no field edict).

Despite the disquieting subject matter, Amity & Sorrow is a well-crafted novel. The prose moves easily between past and future, between mother and daughter. Riley possesses a remarkable ability to prettily describe disturbing events; it’s abrasive, yet compelling. She examines the complexities of families and the need to belong, how we lie best when we lie to ourselves (well said, Stephen King), and the ability to adapt. It’s an accomplished debut novel and one I’d recommend. Rating 3.5/5, suggested song, We Don’t Live Here Anymore by Jakob Dylan.

So, I bid you, go forth and read the book about abandoning your spouse, turning a blind eye to abuse, and encouraging ignorance – in nomine Patris, et Filii, et Spiritus Sancti. Amen.

Dear god, that’s profane. So were the words I used when I learned Morrissey didn’t get into the Hall of Fame. I feel a bit guilty about that…(crosses self).

Ugh, I really am going to hell.

Credo quia absurdum est.

Herbed Pizza

If there is one junk food I enjoy above all else, it’s pizza. Since the characters in Amity & Sorrow grow their own herbs, I though I would suggest Herbed Pizza with Prosciutto, Basil, and Goat Cheese. Best of both worlds and all that.



6 thoughts on “Scientia Potentia Est: Amity & Sorrow by Peggy Riley

  1. Whew, that book sounds heavy. I have always steered clear of “Christian fiction” because it can be so darn heavy-handed, but this sounds like a decent place to start.

    I have always been tempted by the so-called Amish romance genre, though. For some reason, there was always an entire rack of those books at the grocery store in my college town.

    Also I totally want to try that pizza.


    1. It is a bit on the more serious side, but it’s good. The author handles the subject nicely, without having a message one way or the other. The ending disturbed me a bit, you’ll have to let me know what you think if you read it.

      And if the world devolves into madness and there’s hardly a literate person left, the romance genre will be the only one flourishing. The sheer amount that genre produces astounds me.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: